Atraxa, Praetors' Voice

Deckwright deck report · Pvragon · bracket 3 · seed 2234456784

Overview

Commander
Atraxa, Praetors' Voice
Colour identity
WUBG
Requested bracket
3
Power estimate
5.7 of 10 (the deck plays at bracket 3)
Legality
legal in every Commander rule and the requested bracket
Independent check
agrees
Deck
100 cards, build atraxa-praetors-voice-852f1ad0f8 version 1
Seed
2234456784
Data version
engine 0.1.0/milp-1; cards 2026-10-21T09:01:59.312+00:00; combos 2026-10-21T17:15:09.663601+00:00; rules_last_verified 2026-10-20
Priced cards total
$262.10 (cards without a price are not counted)

Deck list

Creature (23)

  • 1 Mikaeus, the Lunarch mv 1
  • 1 Biophagus mv 2
  • 1 Cankerbloom mv 2
  • 1 Gyre Sage mv 2
  • 1 Incubation Druid mv 2
  • 1 Metastatic Evangel mv 2
  • 1 Thrummingbird mv 2
  • 1 Winding Constrictor mv 2
  • 1 Champion of Lambholt mv 3
  • 1 Dreamtide Whale mv 3
  • 1 Evolution Sage mv 3
  • 1 Evolution Witness mv 3
  • 1 Kami of Whispered Hopes mv 3
  • 1 Pensive Professor mv 3
  • 1 Rishkar, Peema Renegade mv 3
  • 1 Atraxa, Praetors' Voice mv 4
  • 1 Crystalline Crawler mv 4
  • 1 Ezuri, Stalker of Spheres mv 4
  • 1 Fathom Mage mv 4
  • 1 Forgotten Ancient mv 4
  • 1 Tekuthal, Inquiry Dominus mv 4
  • 1 Deepglow Skate mv 5
  • 1 Kalonian Hydra mv 5

Planeswalker (3)

  • 1 Nissa, Voice of Zendikar mv 3
  • 1 Jace, Unraveler of Secrets mv 5
  • 1 Vraska, Betrayal's Sting mv 6

Instant (11)

  • 1 Path to Exile mv 1
  • 1 Swords to Plowshares mv 1
  • 1 Arcane Denial mv 2
  • 1 Counterspell mv 2
  • 1 Dovin's Veto mv 2
  • 1 Heroic Intervention mv 2
  • 1 Negate mv 2
  • 1 Ripples of Potential mv 2
  • 1 Inspiring Call mv 3
  • 1 Reject Imperfection mv 3
  • 1 Brokers Confluence mv 5

Sorcery (9)

  • 1 Farseek mv 2
  • 1 Unnatural Restoration mv 2
  • 1 Cultivate mv 3
  • 1 Tezzeret's Gambit mv 4
  • 1 Damning Verdict mv 5
  • 1 Sunfall mv 5
  • 1 Farewell mv 6
  • 1 Merciless Eviction mv 6
  • 1 Rishkar's Expertise mv 6

Artifact (8)

  • 1 Astral Cornucopia mv 0
  • 1 Everflowing Chalice mv 0
  • 1 Sol Ring mv 1
  • 1 Arcane Signet mv 2
  • 1 Ozolith, the Shattered Spire mv 2
  • 1 Swiftfoot Boots mv 2
  • 1 Chromatic Lantern mv 3
  • 1 Insight Engine mv 3

Enchantment (8)

  • 1 Hardened Scales mv 1
  • 1 Hollowmurk Siege mv 2
  • 1 Innkeeper's Talent mv 2
  • 1 Bred for the Hunt mv 3
  • 1 Brokers Ascendancy mv 3
  • 1 Phyrexian Arena mv 3
  • 1 Terrasymbiosis mv 3
  • 1 Inexorable Tide mv 5

Land (38)

  • 1 Arcane Sanctum mv 0
  • 1 Breeding Pool mv 0
  • 1 Command Tower mv 0
  • 1 Evolving Wilds mv 0
  • 1 Exotic Orchard mv 0
  • 1 Forest mv 0
  • 1 Gavony Township mv 0
  • 1 Gemstone Mine mv 0
  • 1 Godless Shrine mv 0
  • 1 Hallowed Fountain mv 0
  • 1 Haven of the Spirit Dragon mv 0
  • 1 Hinterland Harbor mv 0
  • 1 Indatha Triome mv 0
  • 1 Interplanar Beacon mv 0
  • 6 Island mv 0
  • 1 Karn's Bastion mv 0
  • 1 Nesting Grounds mv 0
  • 1 Opal Palace mv 0
  • 1 Opulent Palace mv 0
  • 1 Overgrown Tomb mv 0
  • 1 Path of Ancestry mv 0
  • 1 Sandsteppe Citadel mv 0
  • 1 Seaside Citadel mv 0
  • 1 Spara's Headquarters mv 0
  • 3 Swamp mv 0
  • 1 Temple Garden mv 0
  • 1 Terramorphic Expanse mv 0
  • 1 Vivid Creek mv 0
  • 1 Vivid Grove mv 0
  • 1 Watery Grave mv 0
  • 1 Zagoth Triome mv 0

Mana curve

91192143549556+mana value of nonland cards

Why each card is in the deck

CardRolesReason
Atraxa, Praetors' VoicecommanderCommander: generates value at the start of a phase every turn: "at the beginning of your end step, proliferate."
Command TowerlandLand, which guards against "mana screw or color screw"; played in 95% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC
Tekuthal, Inquiry DominussynergyTriggers Atraxa, Praetors' Voice's text (proliferate); delivers the win line "combat damage from creatures grown with +1/+1 counters"; played in 69% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC
Sol RingrampRamp, counted toward the ramp minimum of 12, which guards against "mana screw or color screw"; played in 86% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC; it reads "{t}: add {c}{c}"
Ezuri, Stalker of Spherescard_advantageCard advantage, counted toward the card advantage minimum of 12, which guards against "running out of cards"; delivers the win line "combat damage from creatures grown with +1/+1 counters"; played in 54% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC
Hardened ScalessynergyDelivers the win line "combat damage from creatures grown with +1/+1 counters"; played in 15% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC; it reads "if one or more +1/+1 counters would be put on a creature you control…"
Brokers AscendancysynergyTriggers Atraxa, Praetors' Voice's text (proliferate); delivers the win line "combat damage from creatures grown with +1/+1 counters"; played in 34% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC
Astral CornucopiarampRamp, counted toward the ramp minimum of 12, which guards against "mana screw or color screw"; triggers Atraxa, Praetors' Voice's text (proliferate); played in 46% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC
Karn's BastionlandLand, which guards against "mana screw or color screw"; delivers the win line "combat damage from creatures grown with +1/+1 counters"; played in 63% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC
Forgotten AncientsynergyTriggers Atraxa, Praetors' Voice's text (proliferate); delivers the win line "combat damage from creatures grown with +1/+1 counters"; played in 14% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC
Fathom Magecard_advantageCard advantage, counted toward the card advantage minimum of 12, which guards against "running out of cards"; played in 17% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC; it reads "evolve"
Arcane Signetfixing, rampColour fixing; ramp, counted toward the ramp minimum of 12, which guards against "mana screw or color screw"; played in 80% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC; it reads "{t}: add one mana of any color in your commander's color identity"
Evolution SagesynergyDelivers the win line "combat damage from creatures grown with +1/+1 counters"; played in 60% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC; it reads "landfall — whenever a land you control enters, proliferate"
Exotic OrchardlandLand, which guards against "mana screw or color screw"; played in 68% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC
ThrummingbirdsynergyDelivers the win line "combat damage from creatures grown with +1/+1 counters"; played in 49% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC; it reads "flying"
Inspiring Callcard_advantage, protectionCard advantage, counted toward the card advantage minimum of 12; protection, counted toward the protection minimum of 4, which guards against "running out of cards"; triggers Atraxa, Praetors' Voice's text (proliferate); delivers the win line "combat damage from creatures grown with +1/+1 counters"
Tezzeret's Gambitcard_advantageCard advantage, counted toward the card advantage minimum of 12, which guards against "running out of cards"; delivers the win line "combat damage from creatures grown with +1/+1 counters"; played in 50% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC
Kami of Whispered HopesrampRamp, counted toward the ramp minimum of 12, which guards against "mana screw or color screw"; delivers the win line "combat damage from creatures grown with +1/+1 counters"; played in 11% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC
Inexorable TidesynergyDelivers the win line "combat damage from creatures grown with +1/+1 counters"; played in 51% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC; it reads "whenever you cast a spell, proliferate"
Everflowing ChalicerampRamp, counted toward the ramp minimum of 12, which guards against "mana screw or color screw"; triggers Atraxa, Praetors' Voice's text (proliferate); played in 38% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC
Innkeeper's TalentsynergyTriggers Atraxa, Praetors' Voice's text (proliferate); delivers the win line "combat damage from creatures grown with +1/+1 counters"; played in 24% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC
FarseekvaluePlayed in 49% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC; it reads "search your library for a plains, island, swamp, or mountain card, pu…"
Deepglow SkatethreatA threat that closes games; played in 31% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC; it reads "when this creature enters, double the number of each kind of counter…"
Champion of LambholtsynergyTriggers Atraxa, Praetors' Voice's text (proliferate); delivers the win line "combat damage from creatures grown with +1/+1 counters"; played in 9% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC
Swords to Plowsharestargeted_removalTargeted removal, counted toward the targeted interaction minimum of 10, which guards against "faster opponent"; played in 58% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC; it reads "exile target creature"
Temple GardenlandLand, which guards against "mana screw or color screw"; played in 52% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC
Overgrown TomblandLand, which guards against "mana screw or color screw"; played in 52% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC
Kalonian HydrasynergyTriggers Atraxa, Praetors' Voice's text (proliferate); delivers the win line "combat damage from creatures grown with +1/+1 counters"; it reads "trample"
Chromatic Lanternfixing, rampColour fixing; ramp, counted toward the ramp minimum of 12, which guards against "mana screw or color screw"; played in 42% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC; it reads "lands you control have "{t}: add one mana of any color.""
Vraska, Betrayal's StingfixingColour fixing, which guards against "mana screw or color screw"; delivers the win line "combat damage from creatures grown with +1/+1 counters"; played in 57% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC
Indatha TriomelandLand, which guards against "mana screw or color screw"; played in 40% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC
Sandsteppe CitadellandLand, which guards against "mana screw or color screw"; played in 31% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC
Opulent PalacelandLand, which guards against "mana screw or color screw"; played in 29% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC
Crystalline Crawlerfixing, rampColour fixing; ramp, counted toward the ramp minimum of 12, which guards against "mana screw or color screw"; triggers Atraxa, Praetors' Voice's text (proliferate); delivers the win line "combat damage from creatures grown with +1/+1 counters"
Spara's HeadquarterslandLand, which guards against "mana screw or color screw"; played in 39% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC
Ozolith, the Shattered SpiresynergyTriggers Atraxa, Praetors' Voice's text (proliferate); delivers the win line "combat damage from creatures grown with +1/+1 counters"; played in 9% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC
Breeding PoollandLand, which guards against "mana screw or color screw"; played in 54% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC
Seaside CitadellandLand, which guards against "mana screw or color screw"; played in 27% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC
Zagoth TriomelandLand, which guards against "mana screw or color screw"; played in 39% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC
Gavony TownshiplandLand, which guards against "mana screw or color screw"; triggers Atraxa, Praetors' Voice's text (proliferate); delivers the win line "combat damage from creatures grown with +1/+1 counters"
Dreamtide WhalesynergyDelivers the win line "combat damage from creatures grown with +1/+1 counters"; played in 32% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC; it reads "vanishing 2"
Godless ShrinelandLand, which guards against "mana screw or color screw"; played in 51% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC
Hallowed FountainlandLand, which guards against "mana screw or color screw"; played in 51% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC
Cultivatefixing, rampColour fixing; ramp, counted toward the ramp minimum of 12, which guards against "mana screw or color screw"; played in 36% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC; it reads "search your library for up to two basic land cards, reveal those card…"
Metastatic EvangelsynergyDelivers the win line "combat damage from creatures grown with +1/+1 counters"; played in 29% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC; it reads "whenever another nontoken creature you control enters, proliferate"
Arcane SanctumlandLand, which guards against "mana screw or color screw"; played in 25% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC
Mikaeus, the LunarchsynergyTriggers Atraxa, Praetors' Voice's text (proliferate); delivers the win line "combat damage from creatures grown with +1/+1 counters"; it reads "this enters with x +1/+1 counters on it"
Watery GravelandLand, which guards against "mana screw or color screw"; played in 50% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC
Damning Verdictmass_removalMass removal, counted toward the mass interaction minimum of 4; played in 8% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC; it reads "destroy all creatures with no counters on them"
Path of Ancestrycard_selection, landCard selection; land, which guards against "mana screw or color screw"; played in 32% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC
Ripples of PotentialprotectionProtection, counted toward the protection minimum of 4, which guards against "commander removed repeatedly"; delivers the win line "combat damage from creatures grown with +1/+1 counters"; played in 19% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC
Evolving WildslandLand, which guards against "mana screw or color screw"; played in 19% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC
Evolution WitnessrecursionRecursion, counted toward the recursion minimum of 2, which guards against "board wiped"; it reads "{1}{g}: adapt 2"
Heroic InterventionprotectionProtection, counted toward the protection minimum of 4, which guards against "commander removed repeatedly"; played in 25% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC; it reads "permanents you control gain hexproof and indestructible until end of…"
Path to Exiletargeted_removalTargeted removal, counted toward the targeted interaction minimum of 10, which guards against "faster opponent"; played in 36% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC; it reads "exile target creature"
Winding ConstrictorthreatA threat that closes games; it reads "if one or more counters would be put on an artifact or creature you c…"
Gyre SagerampRamp, counted toward the ramp minimum of 12, which guards against "mana screw or color screw"; triggers Atraxa, Praetors' Voice's text (proliferate); it reads "evolve"
Incubation DruidrampRamp, counted toward the ramp minimum of 12, which guards against "mana screw or color screw"; triggers Atraxa, Praetors' Voice's text (proliferate); it reads "{t}: add one mana of any type that a land you control could produce"
Counterspellstack_interactionStack interaction, counted toward the targeted interaction minimum of 10, which guards against "opposing combo"; played in 38% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC; it reads "counter target spell"
Opal PalacelandLand, which guards against "mana screw or color screw"; triggers Atraxa, Praetors' Voice's text (proliferate); delivers the win line "combat damage from creatures grown with +1/+1 counters"
Nesting GroundslandLand, which guards against "mana screw or color screw"; played in 12% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC
Bred for the Huntcard_advantageCard advantage, counted toward the card advantage minimum of 12, which guards against "running out of cards"; triggers Atraxa, Praetors' Voice's text (proliferate); delivers the win line "combat damage from creatures grown with +1/+1 counters"
Swiftfoot BootsprotectionProtection, counted toward the protection minimum of 4, which guards against "commander removed repeatedly"; played in 19% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC; it reads "equipped creature has hexproof and haste"
Biophagusfixing, rampColour fixing; ramp, counted toward the ramp minimum of 12, which guards against "mana screw or color screw"; triggers Atraxa, Praetors' Voice's text (proliferate); delivers the win line "combat damage from creatures grown with +1/+1 counters"
Cankerbloomtargeted_removalTargeted removal, counted toward the targeted interaction minimum of 10, which guards against "faster opponent"; delivers the win line "combat damage from creatures grown with +1/+1 counters"; played in 33% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC
Terramorphic ExpanselandLand, which guards against "mana screw or color screw"; played in 15% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC
Rishkar, Peema RenegaderampRamp, counted toward the ramp minimum of 12, which guards against "mana screw or color screw"; triggers Atraxa, Praetors' Voice's text (proliferate); delivers the win line "combat damage from creatures grown with +1/+1 counters"
Unnatural RestorationrecursionRecursion, counted toward the recursion minimum of 2, which guards against "board wiped"; delivers the win line "combat damage from creatures grown with +1/+1 counters"; played in 32% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC
Vivid GrovelandLand, which guards against "mana screw or color screw"; triggers Atraxa, Praetors' Voice's text (proliferate)
Pensive Professorcard_advantageCard advantage, counted toward the card advantage minimum of 12, which guards against "running out of cards"; it reads "increment"
Terrasymbiosiscard_advantageCard advantage, counted toward the card advantage minimum of 12, which guards against "running out of cards"; triggers Atraxa, Praetors' Voice's text (proliferate); it reads "whenever you put one or more +1/+1 counters on a creature you control…"
Hinterland HarborlandLand, which guards against "mana screw or color screw"; played in 17% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC
Phyrexian Arenacard_advantageCard advantage, counted toward the card advantage minimum of 12, which guards against "running out of cards"; played in 20% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC; it reads "at the beginning of your upkeep, you draw a card and lose 1 life"
Sunfallmass_removalMass removal, counted toward the mass interaction minimum of 4; played in 6% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC; it reads "exile all creatures"
Farewellgraveyard_hate, mass_removalGraveyard hate, counted toward the mass interaction minimum of 4; mass removal, counted toward the mass interaction minimum of 4, which guards against "opposing combo"; played in 21% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC; it reads "choose one or more —"
Insight Enginecard_advantageCard advantage, counted toward the card advantage minimum of 12, which guards against "running out of cards"; triggers Atraxa, Praetors' Voice's text (proliferate); played in 10% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC
Hollowmurk Siegecard_advantageCard advantage, counted toward the card advantage minimum of 12, which guards against "running out of cards"; triggers Atraxa, Praetors' Voice's text (proliferate); delivers the win line "combat damage from creatures grown with +1/+1 counters"
Merciless Evictionmass_removalMass removal, counted toward the mass interaction minimum of 4; played in 7% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC; it reads "choose one —"
Arcane Denialstack_interactionStack interaction, counted toward the targeted interaction minimum of 10, which guards against "opposing combo"; played in 9% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC; it reads "counter target spell"
Nissa, Voice of Zendikarcard_advantageCard advantage, counted toward the card advantage minimum of 12, which guards against "running out of cards"; triggers Atraxa, Praetors' Voice's text (proliferate); delivers the win line "combat damage from creatures grown with +1/+1 counters"
Reject Imperfectionstack_interactionStack interaction, counted toward the targeted interaction minimum of 10, which guards against "opposing combo"; delivers the win line "combat damage from creatures grown with +1/+1 counters"; played in 12% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC
Negatestack_interactionStack interaction, counted toward the targeted interaction minimum of 10, which guards against "opposing combo"; played in 10% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC; it reads "counter target noncreature spell"
Rishkar's Expertisecard_advantageCard advantage, counted toward the card advantage minimum of 12, which guards against "running out of cards"; it reads "draw cards equal to the greatest power among creatures you control"
Dovin's Vetostack_interactionStack interaction, counted toward the targeted interaction minimum of 10, which guards against "opposing combo"; played in 11% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC; it reads "this spell can't be countered"
Brokers Confluencestack_interactionStack interaction, counted toward the targeted interaction minimum of 10, which guards against "opposing combo"; delivers the win line "combat damage from creatures grown with +1/+1 counters"; played in 9% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC
Jace, Unraveler of Secretscard_selection, stack_interaction, targeted_removalCard selection; stack interaction, counted toward the targeted interaction minimum of 10, which guards against "faster opponent"; played in 9% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC; it reads "+1: scry 1, then draw a card"
Gemstone MinelandLand, which guards against "mana screw or color screw"; triggers Atraxa, Praetors' Voice's text (proliferate)
Vivid CreeklandLand, which guards against "mana screw or color screw"; triggers Atraxa, Praetors' Voice's text (proliferate)
Interplanar BeaconlandLand, which guards against "mana screw or color screw"; played in 12% of Atraxa decks on EDHREC
Haven of the Spirit Dragonland, recursionLand; recursion, counted toward the recursion minimum of 2, which guards against "mana screw or color screw"
IslandlandBasic land: 6 of the deck's stated lands, the cheapest way to hold the colours Island supplies for the WUBG identity
SwamplandBasic land: 3 of the deck's stated lands, the cheapest way to hold the colours Swamp supplies for the WUBG identity
ForestlandBasic land: 1 of the deck's stated lands, the cheapest way to hold the colours Forest supplies for the WUBG identity

Alternatives per category

Each alternative passes the legality and bracket check as a swap.

Ramp (12 in the deck, minimum 12)

CardReplacesPricePlayed inWhyCheck
Replicating RingRishkar, Peema Renegade$0.4316.2%Swap for Rishkar, Peema Renegade: 16% of Atraxa decks play it (EDHREC synergy +0.06); it also triggers the commander's text (proliferate); mana value 3 against 3 (same); $0.43 against $0.22legal swap
Plague MyrBiophagus$2.5913.8%Swap for Biophagus: 14% of Atraxa decks play it (EDHREC synergy +0.06); it shares the plan theme infect; mana value 2 against 2 (same); $2.59 against $15.14legal swap
Rampant GrowthIncubation Druid$0.3916.5%Swap for Incubation Druid: 17% of Atraxa decks play it (EDHREC synergy -0.00); mana value 2 against 2 (same); $0.39 against $0.78legal swap

Card advantage (12 in the deck, minimum 12)

CardReplacesPricePlayed inWhyCheck
Infectious InquiryRishkar's Expertise$0.3638.4%Swap for Rishkar's Expertise: 38% of Atraxa decks play it (EDHREC synergy +0.16); it shares the plan theme infect; mana value 3 against 6 (cheaper); $0.36 against $1.78legal swap
Distorted CuriosityNissa, Voice of Zendikar$0.286.7%Swap for Nissa, Voice of Zendikar: 7% of Atraxa decks play it (EDHREC synergy +0.02); it shares the plan theme infect; mana value 3 against 3 (same); $0.28 against $1.72legal swap
Marketback WalkerHollowmurk Siege$0.380.0%Swap for Hollowmurk Siege: not on the commander's EDHREC page; found by the engine's role search (the oracle classifier tags it for this category); it also triggers the commander's text (proliferate); it shares the plan theme plus1-counters; mana value 0 against 2 (cheaper); $0.38 against $0.99legal swap

Targeted interaction (10 in the deck, minimum 10)

CardReplacesPricePlayed inWhyCheck
Infectious BiteJace, Unraveler of Secrets$0.5631.1%Swap for Jace, Unraveler of Secrets: 31% of Atraxa decks play it (EDHREC synergy +0.13); it shares the plan theme infect; mana value 2 against 5 (cheaper); $0.56 against $2.73legal swap
Drown in IchorBrokers Confluence$1.0926.4%Swap for Brokers Confluence: 26% of Atraxa decks play it (EDHREC synergy +0.11); it shares the plan theme infect; mana value 2 against 5 (cheaper); $1.09 against $1.40legal swap
Assassin's TrophyDovin's Veto$1.1721.9%Swap for Dovin's Veto: 22% of Atraxa decks play it (EDHREC synergy +0.02); mana value 2 against 2 (same); $1.17 against $2.33legal swap

Mass interaction (4 in the deck, minimum 4)

CardReplacesPricePlayed inWhyCheck
Vraska's FallMerciless Eviction$0.3537.4%Swap for Merciless Eviction: 37% of Atraxa decks play it (EDHREC synergy +0.15); it shares the plan theme infect; mana value 3 against 6 (cheaper); $0.35 against $0.55legal swap
White Sun's TwilightFarewell$0.2816.7%Swap for Farewell: 17% of Atraxa decks play it (EDHREC synergy +0.06); mana value 2 against 6 (cheaper); $0.28 against $4.12legal swap
Elspeth, Sun's ChampionSunfall$0.5814.5%Swap for Sunfall: 14% of Atraxa decks play it (EDHREC synergy +0.07); mana value 6 against 5 (dearer); $0.58 against $0.31legal swap

Protection (4 in the deck, minimum 4)

CardReplacesPricePlayed inWhyCheck
Shalai, Voice of PlentySwiftfoot Boots$1.2119.6%Swap for Swiftfoot Boots: 20% of Atraxa decks play it (EDHREC synergy +0.08); it also triggers the commander's text (proliferate); it shares the plan theme plus1-counters; mana value 4 against 2 (dearer); $1.21 against $1.48legal swap
Mutational AdvantageHeroic Intervention$5.5610.4%Swap for Heroic Intervention: 10% of Atraxa decks play it (EDHREC synergy +0.04); it shares the plan theme infect; mana value 3 against 2 (dearer); $5.56 against $8.96legal swap
DaydreamRipples of Potential$0.320.0%Swap for Ripples of Potential: not on the commander's EDHREC page; found by the engine's role search (the oracle classifier tags it for this category); it also triggers the commander's text (proliferate); it shares the plan theme plus1-counters; mana value 1 against 2 (cheaper); $0.32 against $5.45legal swap

Recursion (3 in the deck, minimum 2)

CardReplacesPricePlayed inWhyCheck
Vat EmergenceHaven of the Spirit Dragon$0.286.7%Swap for Haven of the Spirit Dragon: 7% of Atraxa decks play it (EDHREC synergy +0.02); it shares the plan theme infect; mana value 5 against 0 (dearer); $0.28 against $0.31legal swap
Planewide CelebrationUnnatural Restoration$0.825.5%Swap for Unnatural Restoration: 5% of Atraxa decks play it (EDHREC synergy +0.02); it shares the plan theme infect; mana value 7 against 2 (dearer); $0.82 against $1.22legal swap
Crawl from the CellarEvolution Witness$0.180.0%Swap for Evolution Witness: not on the commander's EDHREC page; found by the engine's role search (the oracle classifier tags it for this category); it also triggers the commander's text (proliferate); it shares the plan theme plus1-counters; mana value 1 against 3 (cheaper); $0.18 against $0.24legal swap

Tutors (0 in the deck, minimum 0)

No alternative found within the limits.

Win cards (33 in the deck, minimum 7)

CardReplacesPricePlayed inWhyCheck
Prologue to PhyresisBrokers Confluence$0.8841.3%Swap for Brokers Confluence: 41% of Atraxa decks play it (EDHREC synergy +0.17); it shares the plan theme infect; mana value 2 against 5 (cheaper); $0.88 against $1.40legal swap
Infectious InquiryReject Imperfection$0.3638.4%Swap for Reject Imperfection: 38% of Atraxa decks play it (EDHREC synergy +0.16); it shares the plan theme infect; mana value 3 against 3 (same); $0.36 against $0.32legal swap
Vraska's FallNissa, Voice of Zendikar$0.3537.4%Swap for Nissa, Voice of Zendikar: 37% of Atraxa decks play it (EDHREC synergy +0.15); it shares the plan theme infect; mana value 3 against 3 (same); $0.35 against $1.72legal swap

Stack interaction (7 in the deck, minimum 7)

CardReplacesPricePlayed inWhyCheck
Bring the EndingJace, Unraveler of Secrets$0.256.6%Swap for Jace, Unraveler of Secrets: 7% of Atraxa decks play it (EDHREC synergy +0.02); it shares the plan theme infect; mana value 2 against 5 (cheaper); $0.25 against $2.73legal swap
Fuel for the CauseBrokers Confluence$0.406.3%Swap for Brokers Confluence: 6% of Atraxa decks play it (EDHREC synergy +0.02); it shares the plan theme infect; mana value 4 against 5 (cheaper); $0.40 against $1.40legal swap
Essence CaptureDovin's Veto$0.210.0%Swap for Dovin's Veto: not on the commander's EDHREC page; found by the engine's role search (the oracle classifier tags it for this category); it also triggers the commander's text (proliferate); it shares the plan theme plus1-counters; mana value 2 against 2 (same); $0.21 against $2.33legal swap

Simulation

20,000 seeded games (seed 14925), 10 turns each; 8 of 8 gates pass.

Gates

Keep the first 781.5%Two or more mulligans3.5%Screw (under 3 mana sources by turn 4)3.4%Flood (3 or more lands stuck in hand at end of turn 7)6.6%Commander on curve86.1%Commander by mana value + 295.0%Interaction seen by turn 481.5%Mana efficiency turns 1 to 689.6%
GateMeasured95% intervalTargetResult
Keep the first 781.5%80.9% to 82.0%at least 80.0%pass
Two or more mulligans3.5%3.2% to 3.8%under 4.0%pass
Screw (under 3 mana sources by turn 4)3.4%3.2% to 3.7%under 5.0%pass
Flood (3 or more lands stuck in hand at end of turn 7)6.6%6.3% to 7.0%under 8.0%pass
Commander on curve86.1%85.6% to 86.6%at least 85.0%pass
Commander by mana value + 295.0%94.7% to 95.3%at least 95.0%borderline
Interaction seen by turn 481.5%80.9% to 82.0%at least 70.0%pass
Mana efficiency turns 1 to 689.6%89.5% to 89.8%between 75.0% and 85.0%pass

With the commander removed on its first cast

same shuffles with the commander left out of the opening hand; the two commander gates do not apply

GateMeasured95% intervalTargetResult
Keep the first 781.5%80.9% to 82.0%at least 80.0%pass
Two or more mulligans3.5%3.2% to 3.8%under 4.0%pass
Screw (under 3 mana sources by turn 4)3.4%3.2% to 3.7%under 5.0%pass
Flood (3 or more lands stuck in hand at end of turn 7)6.9%6.6% to 7.3%under 8.0%pass
Commander on curvedoes not applynot applicablenot applicable
Commander by mana value + 2does not applynot applicablenot applicable
Interaction seen by turn 481.5%80.9% to 82.0%at least 70.0%pass
Mana efficiency turns 1 to 683.5%83.3% to 83.7%between 75.0% and 85.0%pass

Cards most often stuck in hand

Vraska, Betrayal's Sting17.4%Merciless Eviction17.2%Rishkar's Expertise17.2%Farewell16.1%Inexorable Tide7.5%Kalonian Hydra7.3%Brokers Confluence7.2%Jace, Unraveler of Secrets7.1%Sunfall6.9%Deepglow Skate6.7%

drawn by turn 8 and costing more than the most mana available on turn 8; flag above 40%

What the simulation does not model

Combos

1 complete in the deck, 51 one card away, 20 blocked by the bracket.

In the deck

One card away

Blocked by the bracket

Primer

Play style: big board (inferred from the theme +1/+1 Counters).

Early game (turns 1-3)

make every land drop, cast two-mana ramp, and cast Atraxa, Praetors' Voice (mana value 4) around turn 3 with ramp, turn 4 without

Mid game (turns 4-7)

develop creatures and the pieces the theme needs, keep enough back for one board wipe

Late game (turns 8+)

commit the board at overwhelming scale and convert it into a win with combat damage from creatures grown with +1/+1 counters or ten poison counters from infect and toxic creatures, finished with proliferate

Ways to win

  1. Combat damage from creatures grown with +1/+1 counters (cards: Creature, Enchantment (counter doublers), Sorcery (overrun))
  2. Ten poison counters from infect and toxic creatures, finished with proliferate (cards: Creature (infect, toxic), Instant (pump), Artifact or Enchantment (proliferate))
  3. Planeswalker ultimates (cards: Planeswalker, Instant (protection), Enchantment (proliferate))

Combo lines

Commander dependence medium: the commander multiplies the plan but the 99 can carry it: some protection, normal redundancy

Pregame summary

What to tell the table before the game.

Data freshness

Data freshness: rules verified 2026-10-20; card data 2026-10-21; combo data 2026-10-21

Card facts come from Scryfall, rules from the Wizards of the Coast Commander pages, combos from Commander Spellbook. The dates above are when each was last verified or fetched.